Oct
29

A Roundtable on Kendrick Lamar’s “good kid, m.A.A.d city”: A Defense of “Poetic Justice” by Adam Wray

Adam Wray: continuing to ensure that Passion of the Weiss employs more Canadians than Tim Horton’s.

There’s a lot of big talk about this Kendrick Lamar record. Classic, this. Voice of a generation, that. It means nothing. We have no idea how good kid m.A.A.d. city will stand the test of time. It looks and sounds like a quote-unquote “classic” right now, but people said that about Common’s Be, too, so, what the fuck? A year out, it may have lost its luster. Or, it may no longer be possible to make a classic in the image of Illmatic or Blueprint, given the ever-shortening half-life of popular music. All we know for sure is that this record has a lot of people talking.

I want to speak specifically on the much-maligned “Poetic Justice,” which is being framed as the album’s weak link. I want go to go to bat for it.

Let’s start with the plush, spacious Scoop DeVille beat.. Warm chords, sonorous kicks and snares, and that Janet sample pitched up just so. My shit. Once the vocal loop (from the, ahem, classic slow jam “Anytime, Anyplace“) gets its hooks in you, it’s game over. It’s the kind of beat I could toss on loop and accidentally listen to for two hours. Scoop plucked a great sample and set it off with sharp, unfussy drum programming. He trims away the fat and lets a good thing be a good thing, which allows the lyrics to the sit atop the track more than any other beat on the record.

And the lyrics are really, really great. They’re subtly virtuosic and wise, a calm, thoughtful meditation on being young and in love and not beating yourself up when it doesn’t work out. Kendrick displays startling emotional maturity for a 25 year-old: “I mean, you need to hear this: love is not just a verb, it’s you looking in the mirror. Love is not just a verb, it’s you looking forward, maybe.” Yeah, she needs to hear it, but so does he.

It’s a reminder: the people in your life are more than just your foils. They’ve ambitions and histories and thoughts of their own. Spelled out, it sounds oh so trite, but it’s remarkably easy to forget. When you’re young, love can express itself as an act you perform at someone, a pose you strike. But Kendrick gets that it’s just as much about being at peace with yourself. It’s a theme he returns to throughout the record, and an important lesson most of us learn the hard way. And even after we’ve learned it, we sometimes need reminding.

Our mental topography plays a huge role in how we respond to art. Not a new observation, but a true one. I am a silk-soft motherfucker at the best of times, and am currently coming to terms with the dissolution of a serious relationship. So, for me, right now, good kid is a break-up album. (Of course, when you’re in the midst of a break-up, everything is a break-up thing. The cheeseburger you just ate is a break-up cheeseburger.) It’s no wonder “Poetic Justice” connected so strongly with me. The song is about getting over yourself and treating each other well. It’s a message that I needed to hear as much as Sherane or Kendrick did.

Stream:

Posted in Adam Wray, Kendrick Lamar | 5 comments | Read Later

5 comments

  1. aryehhs says:

    October 29, 2012 at 8:39 pm (UTC -7)

    Reply

    As someone who’s not currently going through a breakup…you’re still right. I love this song. Not the Drake verse, but whatever, I can tolerate it. But the Kendrick verses are brilliant, tying together being in love with women, with writing, with music (the extensive Pac references). It lets in some of that joy of being young. It’s also, I think, the least self-conscious song on the record. Kendrick can get downright labyrinthine with how reflexive his music is (Sing About Me), and while he’s phenomenal at it, sometimes a simple expression of emotion works just as well or better. He doesn’t always have to be the David Foster Wallace of this rap shit.

  2. Yah says:

    October 31, 2012 at 10:09 am (UTC -7)

    Reply

    Its the only Jimmy Iovine cum stain on the record. Not because the song is bad, but because the drake feat is going to be used for a radio look. Personally I fully believe ab-soul would have laid a fantastic introspective verse on that pain and enjoyment of love. I still really like the song.

  3. Jessen Fox says:

    October 31, 2012 at 9:47 pm (UTC -7)

    Reply

    People need to get over hating Drake. Dude has proved himself more than enough that he can hang with his bars and that he makes solid music. He’ll always have been on Degrassi, he’ll always be from Canada, and he’ll always sing soft and gentle. None of that changes the fact he writes well, and has a knack for this rap shit.

  4. ehyo says:

    November 1, 2012 at 11:56 am (UTC -7)

    Reply

    This article is not credible. “Be” is a classic on all accounts. From a production perspective, the album was pretty much flawless- Kanye and Dilla, only? Come on. No T-Pain features, no trends, no gimmicks. Seamless flow, no skits, no weak points. Of course, sound is subjective. But big sales (over 800,000 sold), strong reviews (a perfect XXL rating), enduring hits and an impact on pop culture (one of the first releases on G.O.O.D. Music) made “Be” a turning point in Common’s career, as well as Kanye’s. Tracks still get burn today and do not sound dated at all. I don’t understand in what way was “Be” not a classic?

    1. nottooclose says:

      November 1, 2012 at 1:08 pm (UTC -7)

      Reply

      I guess what the author is trying to say is that “Be” is not a classic for people whose interest in hip-hop began when Odd Future came out.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

The Top 50 Albums of 2012

All Gold Everything. Read more

The 50 Best Hip-Hop Songs of 2012

No "All Gold Everything"

Read more

A Bluffer's Guide to Rinse FM

Son Raw surveys London's Best Radio Station

Read more

Follow @passionweiss

Excellent Adventures

  • Jeff Weiss Tumblr
  • Jeff Weiss Writer Page
  • Sach O Tumblr
  • Douglas Martin Tumblr
  • Mobb Deen Tumblr
  • Passion of the Weiss Facebook

Bogus Journeys

  • Jeff Weiss Twitter
  • Son Raw Twitter
  • Douglas Martin Twitter
  • Aaron Matthews Twitter
  • Aaron Frank Twitter
  • Doc Zeus Twitter
  • Matt Shea Twitter
  • Evan Nabavian Twitter
  • Jonah Bromwich Twitter
  • Chris Daly Twitter
  • Tosten Burks Twitter
  • Max Bell Twitter
  • Deen Twitter
  • Jimmy Ness Twitter
  • Slava Pastuk Twitter
  • Adam Wray Twitter
  • Alex Piveysky Twitter
  • Jordan Pedersen Twitter
  • Joshua Lerner Twitter

 

 

  • The 50 Greatest Producers of All-Time #50-1
  • Why Harvard & Stone is Against Rap Music and/or Why I'm Canceling My Participation in Tonight's Show
  • Why Is Big Sean Famous?: An Inquisition
  • The Union Forever: R.I.P White Stripes (1997-2011)
  • Earl Sweatshirt, Lost and Found: An Investigative Report by Doc Zeus

Listening

Jeff Weiss

  • Kevin Gates - The Luca Brasi Story
  • Curren$y - New Jet City
  • The Underachievers - Indigosim
  • Zodiac - Zodiac
  • Mandrill - Mandrill
  • King Sunny Ade - Juju Music
  • Nosaj Thing - Home
  • The Besnard Lakes - Until in Excess, Imperceptible UFO
  • Stan Getz & the Oscar Peterson Trio - Stan Getz & The Oscar Peterson Trio

Sach O

  • A$AP Rocky - Long.Live.A$AP
  • The Underachievers - Indigoism
  • Roc Marciano - Reloaded
  • Wen - Commotion EP
  • Slew Dem - Playground
  • DJ Furious & Wiley - The Eski Sound
  • Waka Flocka Flame - Flockaveli
  • Captain Murphy - Duality
  • Cypress Hill - Temples of Boom
  • Elijah & Skilliam on Rinse.FM

Douglas Martin

  • The Urinals - Negative Capability
  • Ice Age - You're Nothing
  • Wimps - Repeat
  • Beach Fossils - Clash the Truth
  • Eat Skull - III
  • My Bloody Valentine - mbv
  • Grouper- The Man Who Died in His Boat
  • Spacemen 3 - The Perfect Prescription
  • Parquet Courts - Light Up Gold
  • Ty Segall and Mikal Cronin - Reverse Shark Attack

Aaron Matthews

  • Sharon Van Etten - Tramp
  • Robyn Hitchcock & The Egyptians - Fegmania
  • Supergrass - I Should Coco
  • Gunplay - Cops & Robbers

Doc Zeus

  • A$AP Mob - Lord$ Never Worry
  • Meyhem Lauren - Respect the Fly Shit
  • My Bloody Valentine - Loveless
  • Wrecking Crew - Wu-Tang Pulp

Max Bell

  • Black Uhuru - Red/Sinsemilla/The Dub Factor
  • Curren$y - New Jet City
  • Black Sabbath - Paranoid/Master of Reality
  • V/A - Eccentric Soul: The Capsoul Label
  • The Underachievers - Indigoism
  • Souls of Mischief - 93' Til Inifinity
  • Nosaj Thing - Home
  • Giraffage - Needs
  • Teebs - Collections 01

Evan Nabavian

  • Slum Village - Dirty Slums 2
  • John Barry - The Ipcress File
  • Karriem Riggins - Alone Together

Tosten Burks

  • Roc Marciano - Reloaded
  • A$AP Rocky - Long.Live.A$AP
  • Q-Tip - The Renaissance
  • Julian Malone - Enemy
  • Quakers - Quakers
  • Raphael Saadiq - Instant Vintage

Matt Shea

  • Serengeti - C.A.R.
  • Killer Mike - R.A.P. Music
  • El-P Cancer 4 Cure
  • Serengeti - Kenny Dennis EP
  • Ab-Soul - Control System
  • Burn One - The Ashtray
  • Alpine - A is for Alpine
  • Chromatics - Kill for Love
  • Curren$y - The Stoned Immaculate
  • Grand Salvo - Slay Me in My Sleep

Slava P

  • The Underachievers - Indigoism
  • Chester Watson - Phantom
  • Kendrick Lamar - C4
  • 100s - Ice Cold Perm
  • li>King Louie - Drilluminati
  • Kevin Gates - The Luca Brasi Story

Jimmy Ness

  • Chief Keef - Finally Rich
  • Mike Will Made It - Established in 1989 Pt. 2
  • Deftones - Koi No Yokan
  • James Taylor - Greatest Hits
  • Joni Mitchell - Blue

Jonah Bromwich

  • Shlohmo - Laid Out
  • The Underachievers - Indigoism
  • Curren$y - New Jet City
  • Rhye - The Fall
  • Alexander Spit - A Breathtaking Ride to the Other Side
  • Nosaj Thing - Home
  • My Bloody Valentine - mbv
  • Night Slugs All Stars Volume 2
  • Dawn Richard - Goldenheart
  • Chester Watson - Phantom

Adam Wray

  • My Bloody Valentine - mbv
  • Toro y Moi - Anything in Return
  • Lee Sins - Lina/Youth Gone 12"
  • Lee Sins - Fetch/Taken 12"
  • Physical Therapy - Safety Net
  • The Underachievers - Indigoism

Reading

Jeff Weiss

  • Dorothy Parker - The Portable Dorothy Parker

Sach O

  • Rayond Chandler - The Long Goodbye

Douglas Martin

  • Michael Chabon - Telegraph Avenue

Max Bell

  • Richard Ford - Rock Springs
  • Charles Bukowski - War All the Time
  • Tobias Wolff - Back in the World
  • Kate Chopin - Bayou Folk & A Night in Arcadie
  • F. Scott Fitzgerald - The Great Gatsby

Aaron Matthews

  • Pico Lyer - The Lady and the Monk
  • David Thoreau - Walden

Slava P

  • Leo Tolstoy - The Cossacks

Jonah Bromwich

  • Don Delillo - Underworld
  • Adam Mansbach - Rage is Back
  • Italo Calvino - Cosmicomics

Doc Zeus

  • Dan Charnas - The Big Payback

Adam Wray

  • Simon Reynolds - Energy Flash: A Journey Through Rave Music and Dance Culture
  • Evgeny Morozov - The Net Delusion

Alex Piveysky

  • HP Lovecraft - The Dream-quest of Unkown Kadath

Evan Nabavian

  • Jon Burlingame - The Music of James Bond

Watching

Jeff Weiss

  • 30 Rock
  • The Lakers' Existential Laments
  • Mad Men - Season 3

Sach O

  • Django Unchained
  • Lincoln
  • Argo
  • Zero Dark Thirty
  • The Daily Show
  • George Carlin HBO Specials

Douglas Martin

  • Mad Men - Season 5
  • Archer - Seasons 1-4
  • Wristcutters: A Love Story
  • The Mindy Project Season 1
  • Girls Season 2
  • Community Season 1
  • You're Gonna Miss Me: A Film About Roky Erickson
  • Parks & Recreation Season 5
  • Style Wars
  • We Jam Econo: The Story of the Minutemen

Max Bell

  • Californication - Season 6
  • The Twilight Zone
  • Miller's Crossing
  • L.A. Plays Itself
  • Steven Wright Stand Up Material
  • Barfly

Aaron Matthews

  • Simpsons Season 4
  • Goodfellas
  • Searching for Sugarman
  • Community Season 3
  • Looper

Evan Nabavian

  • Seven Psychopaths
  • Zero Dark Thirty
  • Hitchcock

Jonah Bromwich

  • The NBA
  • NBC Comedy
  • New Girl/li>
  • Girls
  • The Colbert Report

Slava P

  • Breaking Bad
  • Zeitgeist
  • House of Cards

Doc Zeus

  • Bronson
  • Breaking Bad
  • Warrior
  • The People vs. George Lucas
  • WWE Monday Night Raw

Matt Shea

  • Mad Men Season 4
  • The Dark Knight Rises
  • Birdsong
  • Sorcerer
  • To Live and Die in LA
  • Extreme Prejudice
  • Romancing the Stone
  • The 13th Warrior
  • Margin Call
  • The Olympics

Adam Wray

  • NBA
  • NHL
  • Portlandia Season 3

Alex Piveysky

  • Boxer's Omen
  • The Hobbit
  • Futurama Season 6
  • Killing Them Softly
  • Get A Life

Inner Sanctum

  • 33 Jones
  • A Human Vacuum (Alfred Soto)
  • Analog Giant
  • Bass is the Place
  • Berkeley Place
  • Bloggerhouse
  • Budget Fashionistas (Douglas Martin)
  • Byron Crawford
  • Clap Cowards (Zilla Rocca)
  • Cooler Than That (Trey Kerby)
  • Diving Off Docks (Renato Pagnani)
  • Drop Tops & Stacey Lattisaw Tapes
  • Hip Hop is Read
  • Metal Lungies
  • Marathonpacks
  • Problem World (Nate Patrin)
  • Screw Rock N' Roll
  • Smoking Section
  • So Much Silence
  • Soul Sides
  • Up North Trips
  • Yours Truly

Miscellaneous Apostles

  • 92 BPM
  • 900 Bats
  • Brooklyn Vegan
  • Fake Shore Drive
  • Fluxblog
  • Gorilla Vs. Bear
  • Hidden Track
  • Hipster Runoff
  • I Am Fuel, You are Friends
  • Largehearted Boy
  • My Old Kentucky Blog
  • Nah Right
  • Nialler9
  • Oceans Never Listen
  • OnSmash
  • Phat Friend
  • Question Mark Exclamation Point
  • ReqEffect
  • Root Blog
  • Sasha Frere-Jones
  • Shabooty
  • Skeet On Mischa
  • Slushy Gutter Summer
  • Some Velvet Blog
  • Sonic Router
  • Steady Bloggin
  • The Rap Up
  • The Rising Storm
  • The Singles Jukebox
  • The T.R.O.Y. Blog
  • Typo-Graphical
  • Unkut
  • Voodoo Funk
  • Wayne and Wax
  • Wediditcollective
  • Whatevs
  • You'll Soon Know

Local Natives

  • Aquarium Drunkard
  • Buzz Bands
  • LA-Underground
  • Rollo & Grady
  • Surfing On Steam
  • The Rawking Refuses to Stop
  • The Scenestar
  • Understanding Media

    • Daytrotter
    • Dusted
    • Hip Hop DX
    • LAIST
    • LA Weekly
    • Los Angeles Times
    • New York Magazine
    • New York Times
    • Pitchfork
    • Resident Advisor
    • Slate
    • State Magazine
    • Stereogum
    • The Agit Reader
    • The Daily Swarm
    • The New Yorker
    • Vanity Fair
    • Fact
    • XLR8R

    The Sporting Life

    • Ball Don't Lie
    • Grantland
    • Hardwood Paroxysm
    • The Basketball Jones
    • The Classical

2011

  • Top 50 Albums
  • Top 50 Hip-Hop Songs

2010

  • Top 25 UK Bass Tracks
  • Top DJ Mixes
  • Top 50 Albums
  • Top 50 Hip-Hop Songs

2009

  • Top 50 Albums
  • Top 50 Non-Rap Songs
  • Top 50 Hip-Hop Songs

2008

  • Top 50 Albums
  • Top 50 Non-Rap Songs (A-L)
  • Top 50 Non-Rap Songs (M-Z)
  • Top 50 Hip-Hop Songs

2007

  • Top 50 Albums
  • Top Local Albums
  • Top 25 Hip-Hop Songs

2006

  • Top 25 Albums
  • Top 25 Rock Songs
  • Top 25 Hip-Hop Songs

Miscellaneous

  • Top 50 Rap Albums of the 00s
  • Top 25 Greatest Hip-Hop Albums of All-Time